Yeah, I know, catchy title, right?
Boston Gal had an good post up this weekend about her Christmas planning. I'm a pretty big admirer of her panache for personal finance planning, and this entry was no exception. Planning for Christmas BEFORE Thanksgiving?! FTW, BG.
The commenters on her site had pretty great anecdotes too: families with secret santas, giving to charities, etc... Sigh, if only things were so easy in my familia.
Here is my (unusual) situation, showing once again, why planning and politics don't mix. First, my family, the Chinese one. Well, it's simple. We're Buddhist, we don't officially celebrate Christmas. We did when my sister and I were little, but that ended sometime in HS, and we no longer get or give anything to one another for Christmas. Once in a while, my sis and I will get something extra special for our mom (we got her a trip on a cruise one year), but those are more in celebration of momentous years than anything else. It doesn't help that sis is in China, so she's only occasionally around for the winter holidays. It's gotten so bad that my family doesn't even get gifts for Loo and Kali. Not bad as in they deserve presents, but there had once been a tradition in our family to give gifts to little ones. But we've gotten lazy. Oops.
So my family is easy peasy, great, right? Well, that is until you get to my husband's side of the family. That is a wicked trouble pot.
So there is J's father, with his second family (which includes two college age kids), J's brother (and now his wife), and J's mother (psycho MIL). This is a family that celebrates Christmas big time. Like you've never seen a home decorated up for Christmas until you've seen their homes. We're talking Christmas towels, 2 Christmas trees, thousands of ornaments, Christmas coasters, Christmas clothes for the decorations, OMFG! And because of his parent's divorce, there is a lot of brute competitiveness along the lines of who does the better Christmas. For as long as I've been w/ J (20 years) we've done Christmas roughly along the lines of spending Christmas Eve with his dad and Christmas Day with his mom. Which involves food, present exchange and grilling about who got who what.
The only way we've managed to balance this is by being relatively extravagant with J's two half-siblings (which gives J's father the warm fuzzies) but modest with J's father and step-mother, and then very extravagant w/ J's mother. Of course, this would even be easy-peasy, except the fact that psycho MIL is ridiculously passive aggressive (remember, she hates my guts). She has repeatedly told us that she doesn't need anymore stuff from her children, and she acts rather distant when opening her presents. But you can always see her subversively looking at the brand and doing that calculation in her head of exactly how much we've spent on her. And she has famously accused J of not caring about her because he neglected to purchase her a present for Mother's Day one year when we were in Asia.
Then there is J's brother, who is apparently a born-again Buddhist private equity manager (I know, the irony) who scorns the Yuppie world's attachment to material goods. Unfortunately, the one year where we attempted to do the whole "contribution to *** given on your behalf," he threw the card in J's face and yelled at J for "supporting the competitor" (sorry can't be more specific, but needless to say, it was not something hugely obvious to anyone except J's brother).
And the end to this family saga is the role played by J and I. J is (as far as I'm concerned) irrationally nostalgic, and I have a stone-cold dead heart. J believes in the "magic of Christmas" and strives for that Currier and Ives picture of familial contentment in front of a warm hearth fire every year. So we Christmas budget each year according to how much money it will take to fix the particular cataclysmic event that happened that year. This year is pretty average. I'm expecting to spend about $400-500 on his family, though I have no idea on what (oh, did I mention that I've been doing J's Christmas shopping for him since the year we met? No? Yeah?)
For J and I as to our own family, we've turned the focus to our daughters. And this is where I come in.
I loved Christmas as a child. Loved, loved, loved it. We were pretty poor as children, since my family immigrated to the US when I was young, and my father had a few bouts with unemployment. But my parents always made sure to make a big deal out of Christmas, I guess as a way to hide the cracks in our own walls (which they did an amazing job of, since I never realized how financially challenged we were until college). But there was always a weird cultural gap in my family between the parents and the children when it came to Christmas. First, we'd get lots of needed clothes. Which made sense, because it made the gift giving seem a much bigger deal than it really was. But we also got toys that were really, well, outdated from the kids' perspective. Or just plain weird. But we'd always spend a portion of Christmas day with our (much wealthier, and actually Christian) uncle's family. And they would just ply us with the good stuff (because we had older cousins who "knew" things about toys).
So being forever tarnished by Christmases past, I've made it a point to give only gifts to the girls that I think they will actually like for their birthdays and Christmas (in other words, no clothing). We're pretty stingy about buying toys for them in between those days, which is, of course, an excuse for me to be extravagant on those days. I'm expecting to spend about $100 on each of the girls for Christmas. This is actually cutting back from what I used to spend on Loo alone for Christmas and will include toys for the girls to give to Toys for Tots.
Then, there is everyone else: Loo's pre-school teachers, my secretary, my nanny, our doorman, etc... This recession is going to be bad. I know everyone is cutting back. J and I are lucky to both be (still) employed with a reasonably great combined salary. This is not a place I'm going to be stingy (I know, I'm seriously sucking on the PF front) because these are folks who help me out a ton, and they really need anything extra they can get. I've already gotten ten Target gift cards, $50 each, to give out at Christmas. I've been in that position, of living paycheck to paycheck, and besides money, there really is nothing better than a gift card (well, except cold, hard cash) to a store that carries the essentials.
Finally, charitable donations. This is the time of the year that J and I give to the Nature Conservancy, our favorite charity, and to our respective colleges/grad schools. Our total year end donations will probably come to between $800-$1000. We might have to revisit this number a bit, because I gave a ton to President-elect Obama during the Presidential election, which I know doesn't count as a charitable deduction, but for us it came out of the same budget as the general charitable donations.
What's your Christmas planning? Are you doing things differently this Christmas?